Navigating Leadership Styles: A Comprehensive Guide
By Natalie McCarty
Olivia Rodrigo; Image Sourced Through Pinterest
Something I get asked about a lot whether in interviews or online is how it is to be leading the team at Gut Instinct. Admittedly, this is my first time being a manager, let alone being my own boss. Suddenly, I’m not just steering my own path but also guiding twenty other people—a responsibility that comes with its own set of challenges. Having dealt with some less-than-ideal bosses in the past, I know firsthand how crucial it is to lead in a way that inspires and supports, not just for the success of Gut Instinct, but for the well-being of each person on the team.
Effective leadership isn’t a one-size-fits-all endeavor. Different situations and team dynamics require different approaches. Understanding the variety of personalities at play, as discussed in my earlier article “Mastering the DISC Language: A Guide for Effective Communication with Diverse Personalities”, is key to adapting your leadership style to the needs of your team.
Image Sourced Through Pinterest
In order to do this, I recently completed a leadership certification through Santander’s Open Academy in the hopes to learn how to be the best leader possible for my team. While I think the fundamentals that make a good leader are obvious, learning the actual different styles and how to integrate them all into a more effective model was an extremely interesting thing to learn.
Image Sourced Through Pinterest
Coercive Leadership: Commanding Authority
Coercive leadership is defined by a leader who demands immediate compliance from their team. This style is characterized by strict guidelines and a clear directive approach, often employed during crises requiring swift action. While effective in emergencies, it can also lead to high levels of resentment and diminished morale.
When to Use:
In urgent situations demanding rapid response.
Where clear direction is essential.
Drawbacks:
May stifle creativity and diminish team morale.
Risks high turnover if overused.
Image Sourced Through Pinterest
Pacesetting Leadership: Leading by Example
Pacesetting leaders are known for setting high performance standards and modeling those expectations themselves. This style can drive exceptional results, particularly with motivated and skilled teams. However, it may also result in burnout if the pace is too intense for team members to maintain.
When to Use:
With highly capable teams that can handle high expectations.
When leading by example is crucial.
Drawbacks:
Can overwhelm team members if expectations are unrealistic.
Risks lack of feedback and support.
Image Sourced Through Pinterest
Affiliative Leadership: Fostering Harmony
Affiliative leadership places a premium on emotional bonds and team harmony. Leaders who adopt this style work to create a positive work environment and resolve conflicts. While it enhances morale and team cohesion, it may sometimes overlook performance issues.
When to Use:
To enhance team morale and resolve conflicts.
When emotional well-being is a priority.
Drawbacks:
Potentially neglects performance issues.
May lead to ambiguity around goals and expectations.
Image Sourced Through Pinterest
Democratic Leadership: Embracing Collaboration
Democratic leaders value participation and collaboration. They seek input from team members and base decisions on consensus. This inclusive approach can boost engagement and creativity but may slow down the decision-making process.
When to Use:
When diverse perspectives are valuable for decision-making.
To promote a collaborative work environment.
Drawbacks:
Decision-making can be prolonged.
Less effective in situations requiring swift decisions.
Image Sourced Through Pinterest
Coaching Leadership: Cultivating Growth
Coaching leadership focuses on individual development and growth. Leaders provide guidance, feedback, and support to help team members reach their full potential. While this style fosters skill-building and performance enhancement, it requires a significant investment of time and resources.
When to Use:
To develop individual skills and professional growth.
To build a strong, capable team.
Drawbacks:
Requires a long-term commitment and may not yield immediate results.
Can be resource-intensive.
Image Sourced Through Pinterest
Visionary Leadership: Inspiring with a Clear Vision
Visionary or authoritative leaders are adept at articulating a compelling vision for the future. They inspire their teams to align with long-term goals and drive innovation. However, this style may sometimes neglect immediate operational details in favor of strategic objectives.
When to Use:
When a clear vision is needed to motivate and align the team.
To foster innovation and strategic direction.
Drawbacks:
May overlook short-term needs.
Requires effective communication to convey the vision.
Image Sourced Through Pinterest
Leadership by Values: Guiding with Principles
Leadership by values emphasizes ethical behavior, integrity, and alignment with organizational principles. Leaders who adopt this style build trust and loyalty by consistently upholding core values. It requires a steadfast commitment to those values to be effective.
When to Use:
To promote ethical behavior and strong organizational culture.
To align actions with core values and mission.
Drawbacks:
May encounter conflicts between values and practical needs.
Requires consistent demonstration of values.
Image Sourced Through Pinterest
Leading Gut Instinct has been an eye-opening journey—one that has challenged me to grow, adapt, and redefine what it means to be a leader. Leading with purpose and empathy is so crucial for the overall health of any team, and understanding and applying the right leadership style is crucial for fostering a productive and motivated team. By recognizing the unique attributes and potential limitations of each style, leaders can adapt their approach to meet the specific needs of their team and achieve their organizational goals. I’m still learning every day, but I’m confident that by continuing to prioritize communication, understanding, and flexibility, we can build something truly remarkable together.
